Monday, August 11, 2008

Alma Lomeli

Mrs. Bosch

AP English Literature 12

7 August 2008

Like Water for Chocolate; Literally
Laura Esquivel’s interest and appeal to writing began back when she was a kindergarten teacher. Her first novel, Like Water for Chocolate was a great hit. The title, meaning intense feelings of either passion or frustration, is a common phrase used in Spanish speaking families. The idea for her novel’s title sprang as she “was cooking the recipes of her mother and grandmother”(Laura Esquivel). Esquivel’s novel was first published in Spanish as Como agua para chocolate, and was later translated to English. Not only was the book a hit, but a movie was even made which had as much success and fame as the novel. Like Water for Chocolate is a novel whose setting is in Mexico during the 19th century. Esquivel’s passion towards the kitchen is revealed in her novel, and served as grand inspiration to her astounding creation. She “believes that the kitchen is the most important part of the house and characterizes it as a source of knowledge and understanding that brings pleasure” (Laura Esquivel). The novel was not only successful in Mexico, but in the US also. It has been translated to more than twenty languages and Esquivel has even won Academy awards for it; something quite exceptional for a Mexican woman who struggled to get to where she is now. Like Water For Chocolate has “received critical acclaim,” raised “new ideas about multiculturalism in literature,” and has “brought attention to the work of previously ignored minority women authors” (Like Water for Chocolate: Context).
Like Water for Chocolate is the story of a young girl named Tita de la Garza who lives with her controlling mother and two older sisters during the Mexican Revolution. Each chapter is titled with the name of the month and each begins with the recipe of a different Mexican platter. Tita is in love with Pedro, but because she is the youngest daughter, and tradition says the youngest may not marry but instead care for her mother until her death, she is denied his hand in marriage. Pedro decides to go through any means possible in order to be close to Tita, so he marries her older sister Rosaura just so they can live under the same house. Tita misinterprets this and holds hard feelings toward Pedro. Tita is amazingly skilled in cooking as a result of growing up in the kitchen. She uses her skills to attract Pedro and he begins to develop a great passion towards her. Tita’s mother, Mama Elena begins to notice this and demands Rosaura and Pedro to move away. Before leaving, Rosaura gives birth to Pedro’s son and Tita cares for him as if he were her own. Later she hears that the baby, Roberto, died and she is completely devastated. Tita’s other sister Gertrudis had also left the house with a revolutionary, so Tita finds herself lonely and her mother believes she’s going crazy so she sends her to an asylum but Dr. Brown comes and helps her and even falls in love with her. Tita’s mother dies and then Tita is engaged to Dr. Brown but still can not forget about Pedro. Pedro and Rosaura return with a daughter named Esperanza. One night they reunite in a night of passion and she becomes pregnant. Rosaura dies and finally Tita and Pedro can share their love. But on their first night of freedom, they die in each other’s arms as they interchange their passionate feelings. The ranch in which they lived in sets on fire and the only thing left is her book of recipes.
Two major themes one encounters throughout Esquivel’s novel are passion and personal struggle. Passion plays a key role in the novel. Tita’s passion for the kitchen leads to the passion aroused by Pedro towards Tita. Passion that even
“Pedro couldn’t resist the smells from the kitchen and was heading towards them. But he stopped stock-ill in the doorway, transfixed by the sight of Tita in that erotic posture. Tita looked up without stopping her grinding and her eyes met Pedro’s. At once their passionate glances fused so perfectly that whoever saw them would have seen but a single look, a singly rhythmic and sensual motion, a single trembling breath, a single desire” (Esquivel 67).
There must be emotions for there to be passion, so Tita’s way of expressing her emotions is through the foods she prepares. One day Pedro awarded Tita with some roses but her mother demanded she get rid of them. Tita decides to use the petals to make “Quail in Rose Petal Sauce,” which she prepared with such emotion and passion that after being consumed by the family, they all later experienced a need to fulfill their own passionate desires. It was then that “with that meal it seemed they had discovered a new system of communication, in which Tita was the transmitter, Pedro the receiver, and poor Gertrudis the medium, the conducting body through which the singular sexual message was passed” (Esquivel 52). Passion has both a positive and negative impact throughout the novel. Positive in the way that they fulfill their desires and transfers them into a whole different world, but negative because it causes problems in the lives of the others such as the older sister Rosaura and the mother Mama Elena.
Another major theme in Esquivel’s novel is personal struggle. All throughout the novel each character involves himself/herself in their own personal struggle. Tita’s personal struggle is trying to live up to her mother’s expectations and yet find true love. Mama Elena’s struggle consists of trying to keep the family tradition in order and dealing with her daughters because each bring her a different concern especially Tita. “What you have done has no name! You have forgotten all morality, respect, and good behavior. You are worthless, a good-for-nothing who doesn’t respect even yourself. You have blackened the name of my entire family, from my ancestors down to this cursed baby you carry in your belly” (Esquivel 173). Mama Elena’s main concern is Tita and how she doesn’t abide to her every command, so she struggles to keep the family together. Rosaura’s struggle is that she is married but can not make herself or her partner happy, she also has health problems which eventually cause her death. Pedro’s personal struggle is that he must care for his child and his family, but desires his true love Tita and is greatly tempted by her appearance and by her cooking. “Pedro couldn’t answer. He hadn’t thought of them until now, and to be honest he didn’t want to hurt them, nor stop seeing his little girl. He had to have a solution fair to all of them. He would have to find one. At least there was one thing certain, Tita would not leave the ranch with John Brown” (Esquivel 193). Gertrudis’ struggle is that she is in between everyone else’s struggles. “Then Gertrudis was tempted to appeal to her sister, but her common sense stopped her. She could not disturb Tita and Pedro in any way at this time perhaps the most critical moment of their lives” (Esquivel 192). It is as if Gertrudis tries to please and help everyone and it becomes too great of a hassle for her to handle and even manage. Each character undergoes sets of challenges through their struggles, but it is their personal struggles which have made them who they are, all part of their rite of passage.
The protagonist of Esquivel’s novel, Tita, played a major role which helped contribute to the themes and overall flow of the story. She welcomes the reader into her own world and it is as if one is in the story as well. She is doomed to be obedient towards her mothers expectations, and suffers constantly because of it. Yet she listens to her heart and rebels a bit and chases her dreams. Tita is very stubborn. She tries her best to make her mother happy but no matter what she does her mother is never pleased. This causes her to be depressed and almost lose her sanity. Tita remained caring and patient thorough the novel despite her mothers accusations. Whether her mother needs her help or her own sister, the one who married the love of her life, Tita was not prideful at all and always was lending a helping hand. After her mothers death, Tita claims to see her spirit throughout the ranch which comes back to haunt her. Then comes the turning point of Tita’s growth. She finally stands up to her mothers spirit and lets her know she no longer will let her manipulate her life and that she will do things for herself. A feature always present by Tita is her passion. Her passion for cooking, and her passion for Pedro. The kitchen, food, and fire all play a key role in the passion transmitted by Tita mainly directed towards Pedro. The kitchen serves as a paradox in the novel because it is Tita’s outlet to a fairytale but can sometimes doom her to a nightmare. The heat and the fire also serve as symbols to spark up the passion and desire throughout the novel. Not only is Tita passionate, but she is also very hard working and emotional. She completes most tasks around the house and has multiple responsibilities. Her emotions control the way she does things but she does a fair job of learning to conserve them to herself. Esquivel shows an example of the role women played during the time of the Mexican Revolution through Tita. The typical woman was to stay at home and care for the family. Tita does that, but manages to find her own true identity and grows to become her own character and not what others want her to be. So in the end Tita finds what she was looking for; true love and her personality.
All in all, Like Water for Chocolate was a remarkable and enjoyable novel to read. It kept me at the edge of my seat and thirsting for more and more. Esquivel did an exceptional job in portraying the themes of the story through her characters. I absolutely loved how she separated the novel into sections and connected the recipes with events happening in the story. The diction Esquivel uses is marvelous and really spiced up the novel. Her descriptive words when talking about emotions or scents made me feel as if I was present. Esquivel’s style of writing is often compared to that of Isabel Allende, which is also one of my favorite authors, but hands down I enjoyed Laura Esquivel’s work way more. I believe this novel should be included on a list o works of high literary merit because the way the novel unravels is quite admirable. Being a Latina I related to the book in multiple ways, but I truly believe that anybody can relate to the story somehow. I choose the novel not knowing what to expect, like buying a lottery ticket and finding out that you’ve hit the jackpot. It was just that good, and just that enthralling. If one is looking for a book that transfers you into a whole other world and takes you on a ride on the search of love and individuality, Like water for Chocolate fits it to the T. After reading a book like this, it encourages you to continue looking for books that will come close to having a similar effect. No description could even begin to cover how astounding the novel is and why it deserves sky high praise.























Work Cited

Esquivel, Laura. Like Water for Chocolate. New York: Doubleday, 1992.

Laura Esquivel. 6 Aug. 2008. Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. 7 Aug. 2008.



Like Water for Chocolate: Context. July 2008. Sparknotes LLC. 7 Aug. 2008.